 |
|
 |
| Stanley Cup championship seasons: none |
| Last Stanley Cup championship: none in 23 seasons |
| Quebec Bulldogs became Hamilton Tigers in 1920-21 season |
| Hamilton Tigers became New York Americans in 1925-26 season |
| New York Americans became Brooklyn Americans in 1941-42 season |
| Brooklyn Americans folded after the 1941-42 season |
| Best finish: |
| Que Bulldogs finished 4-20-0 (8 pts) in 1919-20 season |
| Hamilton finished 19-10-1 (39 pts) in 1924-25 season |
| NY Americans lost to Toronto in Stanley Cup Semifinals in 1935-36 season |
| NY Americans lost to Chicago in Stanley Cup Semifinals in 1937-38 season |
| Brooklyn finished 16-29-3 (35 pts) in Eastern Division in 1941-42 season |
| TEAM | SEASON | RECORD | PTS | DIV STAND | CNF STAND | PLAYOFFS |
| Que Bulldogs | 1919-20 | 4-20-0 | 8 pts | 4th NHL | missed playoffs | |
| Hamilton | 1920-21 | 6-18-0 | 12 pts | 4th NHL | missed playoffs | |
| Hamilton | 1921-22 | 7-17-0 | 14 pts | 4th NHL | missed playoffs | |
| Hamilton | 1922-23 | 6-18-0 | 12 pts | 4th NHL | missed playoffs | |
| Hamilton | 1923-24 | 9-15-0 | 18 pts | 4th NHL | missed playoffs | |
| Hamilton | 1924-25 | 19-10-1 | 39 pts | 1st NHL | missed playoffs | |
| NY Americans | 1925-26 | 12-20-4 | 28 pts | 5th NHL | missed playoffs | |
| NY Americans | 1926-27 | 17-25-2 | 36 pts | 4th Intern | missed playoffs | |
| NY Americans | 1927-28 | 11-27-6 | 28 pts | 5th Intern | missed playoffs | |
| NY Americans | 1928-29 | 19-13-12 | 50 pts | 2nd Intern | LNYR | |
| NY Americans | 1929-30 | 14-25-5 | 33 pts | 5th Intern | missed playoffs | |
| NY Americans | 1930-31 | 18-16-10 | 46 pts | 4th Intern | missed playoffs | |
| NY Americans | 1931-32 | 16-24-8 | 40 pts | 4th Intern | missed playoffs | |
| NY Americans | 1932-33 | 15-22-11 | 41 pts | 4th Intern | missed playoffs | |
| NY Americans | 1933-34 | 15-23-10 | 40 pts | 4th Intern | missed playoffs | |
| NY Americans | 1934-35 | 12-27-9 | 33 pts | 4th Intern | missed playoffs | |
| NY Americans | 1935-36 | 16-25-7 | 39 pts | 3rd Intern | WChi LTor | |
| NY Americans | 1936-37 | 15-29-4 | 34 pts | 4th Intern | missed playoffs | |
| NY Americans | 1937-38 | 19-18-11 | 49 pts | 2nd Intern | WNYR LChi | |
| NY Americans | 1938-39 | 17-21-10 | 44 pts | 4th East Div | LTor | |
| NY Americans | 1939-40 | 15-29-4 | 34 pts | 6th East Div | LDet | |
| NY Americans | 1940-41 | 8-29-11 | 27 pts | 7th East Div | missed playoffs | |
| Brooklyn | 1941-42 | 16-29-3 | 35 pts | 7th East Div | missed playoffs |