| TEAM | SEASON | RECORD | PERC | CNF STAND | CNF REC | CNF PERC | FINISH |
| Muhlenburg | 1900-01 | 3-3 | .500 | Independent | no playoff | ||
| Muhlenburg | 1901-02 | 5-6 | .455 | Independent | no playoff | ||
| Muhlenburg | 1902-03 | 6-4 | .600 | Independent | no playoff | ||
| Muhlenburg | 1906-07 | 4-3 | .571 | Independent | no playoff | ||
| Muhlenburg | 1907-08 | 4-1 | .800 | Independent | no playoff | ||
| Muhlenburg | 1912-13 | 8-5 | .615 | Independent | no playoff | ||
| Muhlenburg | 1913-14 | 4-10 | .286 | Independent | no playoff | ||
| Muhlenburg | 1914-15 | 12-5 | .706 | Independent | no playoff | ||
| Muhlenburg | 1915-16 | 5-6 | .455 | Independent | no playoff | ||
| Muhlenburg | 1916-17 | 2-4 | .333 | Independent | no playoff | ||
| Muhlenburg | 1917-18 | 0-7 | .000 | Independent | no playoff | ||
| Muhlenburg | 1918-19 | 7-11 | .389 | Independent | no playoff | ||
| Muhlenburg | 1919-20 | 8-9 | .471 | Independent | no playoff | ||
| Muhlenburg | 1920-21 | 14-11 | .560 | Independent | no playoff | ||
| Muhlenburg | 1921-22 | 10-9 | .526 | Independent | no playoff | ||
| Muhlenburg | 1922-23 | 9-10 | .474 | Independent | no playoff | ||
| Muhlenburg | 1923-24 | 11-5 | .688 | Independent | no playoff | ||
| Muhlenburg | 1924-25 | 11-6 | .647 | Independent | no playoff | ||
| Muhlenburg | 1925-26 | 9-6 | .600 | Independent | no playoff | ||
| Muhlenburg | 1926-27 | 9-7 | .563 | Independent | no playoff | ||
| Muhlenburg | 1927-28 | 6-11 | .353 | Independent | no playoff | ||
| Muhlenburg | 1928-29 | 9-4 | .692 | Independent | no playoff | ||
| Muhlenburg | 1929-30 | 9-8 | .529 | Independent | no playoff | ||
| Muhlenburg | 1930-31 | 6-9 | .400 | Independent | no playoff | ||
| Muhlenburg | 1931-32 | 4-15 | .211 | Independent | no playoff | ||
| Muhlenburg | 1932-33 | 9-11 | .450 | Independent | no playoff | ||
| Muhlenburg | 1933-34 | 11-6 | .647 | Independent | no playoff | ||
| Muhlenburg | 1934-35 | 14-5 | .737 | Independent | no playoff | ||
| Muhlenburg | 1935-36 | 5-16 | .238 | Independent | no playoff | ||
| Muhlenburg | 1936-37 | 9-9 | .500 | Independent | no playoff | ||
| Muhlenburg | 1937-38 | 9-11 | .450 | Independent | no playoff | ||
| Muhlenburg | 1938-39 | 13-8 | .619 | Independent | no playoff | ||
| Muhlenburg | 1939-40 | 11-9 | .550 | Independent | no playoff | ||
| Muhlenburg | 1940-41 | 13-10 | .565 | Independent | no playoff | ||
| Muhlenburg | 1941-42 | 17-7 | .708 | Independent | no playoff | ||
| Muhlenburg | 1942-43 | 13-8 | .619 | Independent | no playoff | ||
| Muhlenburg | 1943-44 | 20-5 | .800 | Independent | no playoff | ||
| Muhlenburg | 1944-45 | 24-4 | .857 | Independent | no playoff | ||
| Muhlenburg | 1945-46 | 23-5 | .821 | 2nd MASC North | 7-1 | .875 | no playoff |
| Muhlenburg | 1946-47 | 19-7 | .731 | 1st MASC North | 7-1 | .875 | no playoff |
| Muhlenburg | 1947-48 | 21-4 | .840 | 1st MASC North | 8-0 | 1.000 | no playoff |
| Muhlenburg | 1948-49 | 17-8 | .680 | 1st MASC North | 6-2 | .750 | no playoff |
| Muhlenburg | 1949-50 | 17-6 | .739 | Independent | no playoff | ||
| Muhlenburg | 1950-51 | 11-14 | .440 | Independent | no playoff | ||
| Muhlenburg | 1951-52 | 10-13 | .435 | Independent | no playoff | ||
| Muhlenburg | 1952-53 | 13-10 | .565 | Independent | no playoff | ||
| Muhlenburg | 1953-54 | 12-10 | .545 | Independent | no playoff | ||
| Muhlenburg | 1954-55 | 14-11 | .560 | Independent | no playoff | ||
| Muhlenburg | 1955-56 | 15-10 | .600 | Independent | no playoff | ||
| Muhlenburg | 1956-57 | 17-9 | .654 | Independent | no playoff | ||
| Muhlenburg | 1957-58 | 12-12 | .500 | Independent | no playoff | ||
| Muhlenburg | 1958-59 | 13-9 | .591 | 3rd Mid-Atlantic | 8-6 | .571 | no playoff |
| Muhlenburg | 1959-60 | 8-18 | .308 | 9th Mid-Atlantic | 3-11 | .214 | no playoff |
| Muhlenburg | 1960-61 | 5-20 | .200 | 9th Mid-Atlantic | 2-12 | .143 | no playoff |
| Muhlenburg | 1961-62 | 5-17 | .227 | 10th Mid-Atlantic | 1-12 | .077 | no playoff |
| Muhlenburg | 1962-63 | 4-17 | .190 | 9th Mid-Atlantic | 0-11 | .000 | no playoff |