 |
|
 |
| Stanley Cup championship seasons: none |
| Last Stanley Cup championship: none in 23 seasons |
| Best finish: |
| lost to Boston in Eastern Conference Semifinals in 2018-19 season |
| TEAM | SEASON | RECORD | PTS | DIV STAND | CNF STAND | PLAYOFFS |
| Columbus | 2000-01 | 28-39-9-6 | 71 pts | 5th Central | --- West | missed playoffs |
| Columbus | 2001-02 | 22-47-8-5 | 57 pts | 5th Central | --- West | missed playoffs |
| Columbus | 2002-03 | 29-42-8-3 | 69 pts | 5th Central | --- West | missed playoffs |
| Columbus | 2003-04 | 25-45-8-4 | 62 pts | 4th Central | --- West | missed playoffs |
| Columbus | 2005-06 | 35-43-4 | 74 pts | 3rd Central | --- West | missed playoffs |
| Columbus | 2006-07 | 33-42-7 | 73 pts | 4th Central | --- West | missed playoffs |
| Columbus | 2007-08 | 34-36-12 | 80 pts | 4th Central | --- West | missed playoffs |
| Columbus | 2008-09 | 41-31-10 | 92 pts | 4th Central | 7th West | LDet |
| Columbus | 2009-10 | 32-35-15 | 79 pts | 5th Central | --- West | missed playoffs |
| Columbus | 2010-11 | 34-35-13 | 81 pts | 5th Central | --- West | missed playoffs |
| Columbus | 2011-12 | 29-46-7 | 65 pts | 5th Central | --- West | missed playoffs |
| Columbus | 2012-13 | 24-17-7 | 55 pts | 4th Central | --- West | missed playoffs |
| Columbus | 2013-14 | 43-32-7 | 93 pts | 4th Metropolitan | 7th East | LPit |
| Columbus | 2014-15 | 42-35-5 | 89 pts | 5th Metropolitan | --- East | missed playoffs |
| Columbus | 2015-16 | 34-40-8 | 76 pts | 8th Metropolitan | --- East | missed playoffs |
| Columbus | 2016-17 | 50-24-8 | 108 pts | 3rd Metropolitan | 4th East | LPit |
| Columbus | 2017-18 | 45-30-7 | 97 pts | 4th Metropolitan | 7th East | LWsh |
| Columbus | 2018-19 | 47-31-4 | 98 pts | 5th Metropolitan | 8th East | WTB LBos |
| Columbus | 2019-20 | 33-22-15 | 81 pts | 6th Metropolitan | 9th East | WTor LTB |
| Columbus | 2020-21 | 18-26-12 | 48 pts | 8th Cent Div | missed playoffs | |
| Columbus | 2021-22 | 37-38-7 | 81 pts | 6th Metropolitan | --- East | missed playoffs |
| Columbus | 2022-23 | 25-48-9 | 59 pts | 8th Metropolitan | --- East | missed playoffs |
| Columbus | 2023-24 | 27-43-12 | 66 pts | 8th Metropolitan | --- East | missed playoffs |
| Columbus | 2024-25 | 40-33-9 | 89 pts | 4th Metropolitan | --- East | missed playoffs |