 |
|
 |
| DATE | SCORE | MVP | VENUE | LOCATION |
| Wed Jul 23 2025 | Liga MX AS vs MLS All-Stars | First Last, Team | Q2 Stadium | Austin, TX |
| Wed Jul 24 2024 | Liga MX All-Stars 4, MLS All-Stars 1 | Juan Brunetta, Liga MX | Lower.com Field | Columbus, OH |
| Wed Jul 19 2023 | Arsenal FC 5, MLS All-Stars 0 | Bukayo Saka, Arsenal | Audi Field | Washington, DC |
| Wed Aug 10 2022 | MLS All-Stars 2, Liga MX All-Stars 1 | Dayne St Clair, Min | Allianz Field | Minneapolis, MN |
| Wed Aug 25 2021 | MLS All-Stars 1, Liga MX All-Stars 1 (3-2 PK) | Matt Turner, NE | Banc of California Stadium | Los Angeles, CA |
| Wed Jul 31 2019 | Atletico Madrid 3, MLS All-Stars 0 | Marcos Liorente, Atletico Madrid | Exploria Stadium | Orlando, FL |
| Wed Aug 1 2018 | Juventus 1, MLS All-Stars 1 (5-3 PK) | Josef Martinez, Atl | MercedesBenz Stadium | Atlanta, GA |
| Wed Aug 2 2017 | Real Madrid 1, MLS All-Stars 1 (4-2 PK) | Borja Mayoral, Real Madrid | Soldier Field | Chicago, IL |
| Thu Jul 28 2016 | Arsenal 2, MLS All-Stars 1 | Chuba Akpom, Arsenal | Avaya Stadium | San Jose, CA |
| Wed Jul 29 2015 | MLS All-Stars 2, Tottenham Hotspur 1 | Kaka, Orl | Dick's Sporting Goods Park | Commerce City, CO |
| Fri Aug 6 2014 | MLS All-Stars 2, Bayern Munich 1 | Landon Donovan, LA | Providence Park | Portland, OR |
| Wed Jul 31 2013 | Roma 3, MLS All-Stars 1 | Alessandro Florenzi, Roma | Sporting Park | Kansas City, KS |
| Wed Jul 25 2012 | MLS All-Stars 3, Chelsea 2 | Chris Pontius, Phi | PPL Park | Chester, PA |
| Wed Jul 27 2011 | Manchester United 4, MLS All-Stars 0 | Park Ji-Sung, Manchester United | Red Bull Arena | Harrison, NJ |
| Wed Jul 28 2010 | Manchester United 5, MLS All-Stars 2 | Federico Macheda, Manchester United | Reliant Stadium | Houston, TX |
| Wed Jul 29 2009 | Everton 1, MLS All-Stars 1 (4-3 PK) | Tim Howard, Everton | Rio Tinto Stadium | Sandy, UT |
| Thu Jul 24 2008 | MLS All-Stars 3, West Ham United 2 | Cuauhtemoc Blanco, Chi | BMO Field | Toronto, Ont |
| Thu Jul 19 2007 | MLS All-Stars 2, Celtic 0 | Juan Pablo Angel, NYR | Dick's Sporting Goods Park | Commerce City, CO |
| Sat Aug 5 2006 | MLS All-Stars 1, Chelsea 0 | Dwayne De Rosario, Hou | Toyota Park | Bridgeview, IL |
| Sat Jul 30 2005 | MLS All-Stars 4, Fulham 1 | Taylor Twellman, NE | Columbus Crew Stadium | Columbus, OH |
| Sat Jul 31 2004 | East 3, West 2 | Amado Guevara, Met | RFK Stadium | Washington, DC |
| Sat Aug 2 2003 | MLS All-Stars 3, Guadalajara 1 | Carlos Ruiz, LA | Home Depot Center | Carson, CA |
| Sat Aug 3 2002 | MLS All-Stars 3, United States 1 | Marco Etcheverry, DC | RFK Stadium | Washington, DC |
| Sat Jul 28 2001 | East 6, West 6 | Landon Donovan, SJ | Spartan Stadium | San Jose, CA |
| Sat Jul 29 2000 | East 9, West 4 | Mamadou Diallo, TB | Columbus Crew Stadium | Columbus, OH |
| Sat Jul 17 1999 | West 6, East 4 | Preki, KCW | Qualcomm Stadium | San Diego, CA |
| Sun Aug 2 1998 | MLS USA 6, MLS World 1 | Brian McBride, Col | Citrus Bowl | Orlando, FL |
| Wed Jul 9 1997 | East 5, West 4 | Carlos Valderrama, East | Giants Stadium | East Rutherford, NJ |
| Sun Jul 14 1996 | East 3, West 2 | Carlos Valderrama, East | Giants Stadium | East Rutherford, NJ |