| TEAM | SEASON | RECORD | PERC | CNF STAND | CNF RECORD | CNF PERC |
| Presbyterian | 1915 | 4-4 | .500 | Independent | ||
| Presbyterian | 1916 | 4-3 | .571 | Independent | ||
| Presbyterian | 1917 | 8-1 | .889 | Independent | ||
| Presbyterian | 1918 | 2-0 | 1.000 | Independent | ||
| Presbyterian | 1919 | 4-3-2 | .556 | Independent | ||
| Presbyterian | 1920 | 5-1-1 | .786 | Independent | ||
| Presbyterian | 1921 | 1-7 | .125 | Independent | ||
| Presbyterian | 1922 | 6-2-1 | .722 | Independent | ||
| Presbyterian | 1923 | 4-3-1 | .563 | Independent | ||
| Presbyterian | 1924 | 1-6-1 | .188 | Independent | ||
| Presbyterian | 1925 | 3-6 | .333 | Independent | ||
| Presbyterian | 1926 | 7-2 | .778 | Independent | ||
| Presbyterian | 1935 | 2-7 | .222 | Independent | ||
| Presbyterian | 1936 | 3-6 | .333 | Independent | ||
| Presbyterian | 1944 | 3-6 | .333 | Independent | ||
| Presbyterian | 1945 | 1-6 | .143 | Independent |