| TEAM | SEASON | RECORD | PERC | CNF STAND | CNF RECORD | CNF PERC |
| Amherst | 1877 | 1-0 | 1.000 | Independent | ||
| Amherst | 1878 | 1-3 | .250 | Independent | ||
| Amherst | 1881 | 0-3-1 | .125 | Independent | ||
| Amherst | 1882 | 1-3 | .250 | Independent | ||
| Amherst | 1886 | 3-4 | .429 | Independent | ||
| Amherst | 1887 | 4-6 | .400 | Independent | ||
| Amherst | 1888 | 2-8-1 | .227 | Independent | ||
| Amherst | 1889 | 3-5-2 | .400 | Independent | ||
| Amherst | 1890 | 6-5-1 | .542 | Independent | ||
| Amherst | 1891 | 8-4-3 | .633 | Independent | ||
| Amherst | 1892 | 9-5 | .643 | Independent | ||
| Amherst | 1893 | 7-6-1 | .536 | Independent | ||
| Amherst | 1894 | 7-5-1 | .577 | Independent | ||
| Amherst | 1895 | 6-5 | .545 | Independent | ||
| Amherst | 1896 | 3-6-1 | .350 | Independent | ||
| Amherst | 1897 | 2-6-2 | .300 | Independent | ||
| Amherst | 1898 | 4-5-1 | .450 | Independent | ||
| Amherst | 1899 | 4-7-1 | .375 | Independent | ||
| Amherst | 1900 | 4-7-1 | .375 | Independent | ||
| Amherst | 1901 | 4-6-2 | .417 | Independent | ||
| Amherst | 1902 | 7-3 | .700 | Independent | ||
| Amherst | 1903 | 7-3 | .700 | Independent | ||
| Amherst | 1904 | 9-1 | .900 | Independent | ||
| Amherst | 1905 | 3-1-2 | .667 | Independent | ||
| Amherst | 1906 | 3-3-1 | .500 | Independent |